Chicano Park’s new mural has fans, detractors

Check out the polarizing image below!

Original post by Kate Morrissey found here: http://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/news/immigration/sd-me-chicano-park-20170414-story.html

One of the first artists to paint in Chicano Park has finished a new mural, one depicting the plight of migrant workers and denouncing President Donald Trump’s planned border wall.

Salvador “Sal” Barajas was part of a group of artists who painted the “Historical Mural” in the park in 1973 that features the leaders and history of the Chicano movement. While Barajas also worked on a restoration project for the park’s many murals several years ago, the new mural is the first time Barajas has put up his own work in the park since 1973.

Park enthusiasts are pleased with the new mural, on the south side of a pillar of the Coronado bridge. Many who support Trump’s border wall are upset at the mural’s message.

Barajas’s latest piece was commissioned almost a decade ago by Border Angels, a migrant rights group known for putting water in the desert to keep border crossers from dying of thirst. This year, the nonprofit group finally had enough funding to make the mural a reality, at a cost of about $10,000.

The mural shows a worker sending money back to his family in Mexico while being strangled by two hands. One hand represents U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, which is responsible for deporting people from the U.S. The other hand represents Mexican government officials, whose corruption makes it necessary for Mexicans to migrate for work, Barajas said.

The bottom of the piece pays homage to Roberto Martinez and Micaela Saucedo, two activists who worked with Border Angels. A large cross toward the bottom reads, “No Border Wall.” Another one carries a Border Angels slogan, “Love has no borders.”

The text “No Border Wall” was one of the last things added to the piece, Barajas said, though the overall message and image was largely the same as what was planned when Border Angels first commissioned the work.

“We are minorities, and minorities have been oppressed for so long,” Barajas said in an interview at the park. “We have to express our feelings. We have it in our DNA.”

Barajas was born in Mexico and sponsored by his father, who was living and working legally in the U.S., to move to San Diego when he was 17, he said. He talked about struggles with racial profiling, low wages and lack of resources that his community experienced as he came of age in Barrio Logan before joining the U.S. Air Force.

“When you’re a minority, you’re faced with realities like this all the time,” Barajas said.

Jesus Amaro, who lives in Mission Gorge, stood admiring the new mural at Chicano Park on Thursday while his daughter played on the playground. He brings her to Chicano Park often, he said, because he likes the community.

“It’s great work, especially for the community around here,” Amaro said when asked about the mural. “It’s a whole united message, everybody coming together and standing for everybody’s rights.”

All of the murals tell the stories about the history of the park’s community, he said, and he was happy to see one added that reflected current events.

Word of the mural has spread further than Chicano Park, and some don’t welcome it. Patti Brasga, a Vista resident, received an email from a friend with a picture of the mural.

“These kinds of people and incendiary statements only serve to divide us and elevate the discord and hate,” she said via email.

Suellen Shea of Vista took issue with the imagery Barajas used. Shea hasn’t seen the mural in person but has seen pictures of it, she said.

“The artist has talent, but, in my opinion, much of it is offensive and anti-American, especially the ICE agent choking the migrant worker,” Shea said via email. “American Citizens want safety & sovereignty (enforced borders) for our country. Nothing strange or racist about that – Mexico does too.”

Several San Diegans who were bothered by the new mural, as well as other murals at the park, said they don’t think public parks should have art with political messages.

“San Diego has many parks,” wrote Carol Hamilton, an Imperial Beach resident who also received an email about the mural. “Only one is splattered with garish posters and anti-American slurs — Chicano Park. A national shrine? I don’t think so. It’s time to whitewash it and use it as a park and not for politics.”

Chicano Park was designated a National Historic Landmark in January.

The Chicano Park Steering Committee, a nonprofit, is responsible for approving any murals or other additions to the park. Neither the city nor the California Department of Transportation is involved, Barajas said, though Caltrans could step in if the department disapproved of a piece.

That committee was formed at the same time as the park was founded. Chicano Park was created when the Barrio Logan community, reeling from losing homes to make way for Interstate 5, gathered there in 1970 to stop California Highway Patrol from building a patrol station under the Coronado Bridge.

Isidro Ortiz, a professor of Chicana and Chicano Studies at San Diego State University, said the act of claiming land for a park was in line with one of the principles of the Chicano movement — self-determination.

“The community has the right to determine its own destiny,” Ortiz said.

The Chicano movement, Ortiz said, was a way for people of Mexican origin living in the U.S. and coming of age in the 1960s to get a sense of identity.

“We were neither accepted as Americans nor accepted as Mexicans,” Ortiz said. “We were living in a twilight zone. It can be very confusing because you really don’t know who you are.”

Ortiz said Barajas’ new mural is a continuation of the resistance to oppression that has been an important part of Chicano identity, and, to him, that resistance is still important.

“The oppression has not ended,” Ortiz said. “It’s still there.”

Chicanos see the park as belonging to them because they believe their ancestors have a claim to the land that predates the City of San Diego, Caltrans or any other U.S. government entity, through Aztlán, the ancestral home of the Aztecs, which stretched from California to Texas.

Enrique Morones, founder of Border Angels, said he doesn’t think the mural is anti-American.

“How can you say that’s un-American when freedom of speech is a right that Americans have?” Morones said over the phone. “I’m absolutely convinced that most people don’t have that point of view.”

Morones said he has received mostly positive feedback on the new mural. One young woman was moved to tears by its message, he said.

“Being against the border wall does not mean that you’re against the sovereignty of one nation or respecting the law,” Morones added. “Building a wall is a message of hate not only to Mexico but to the entire world.”

The anti-wall message, he said, was originally intended to comment on fencing that was planned for the border a decade ago. In today’s political climate, he wanted to make that message clear.

“I think it needs to be directly said,” Morones said. “We cannot be silent.”

The annual Chicano Park Day celebration will take place on Saturday, April 22.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s